My thoughts on the coalition vote on tuition fees

The short version of this post is that I think the decision stinks and I am ashamed of the way the most senior members of the Lib Dems have seemingly ignored party policy and reneged on their election pledges.  I am staggered.  Just this week I have been really upset to hear young people I know having lost all their aspirations to go to University because the sort of debt figures they are facing are numbers they cannot even consider, however much later in life and higher in salary they might have to pay them off.

I represent a ward that is about 65% students and I am feeling like they have all been terribly let down by my party.  I have considered resigning, and indeed Richard Huzzey, who used to be a City Councillor for Holywell Ward until his academic career took him abroad, had indeed done so.  He’s written an excellent article about it in Lib Dem Voice.

I could leave the Lib Dems over this but all that would achieve is effectively terminating any representation I can offer for students, and the other people that live in Carfax, to Oxford City Council.  As an independent I would immediately have virtually no voice, no committee seats and no power.  It would make me far less effective as a representative of those who elected me.  We may not like it, but that’s the way party groups work in local authorities.  It’s the law!  I stood as a LibDem in 2010 and was elected by nearly 1000 people who I believe expected me to represent them as a LibDem for four years. I don’t intend to renege on that promise even if my party’s MPs have reneged on theirs. I certainly won’t be joining any other parties as if people in Carfax ward had wanted a councillor from another party I guess they would have voted for one.

To those who say that we’re in  a coalition so we can’t win all the battles and pursue everything in our manifesto, that’s true but  not pursuing a policy is one thing – that’s called abstention.
Pursuing an entirely opposite and contrary policy is entirely different – that’s called selling out and reneging on promises.  The first is pragmatic, the second is shameful.

I can entirely sympathise with those who feel the Lib Dem government ministers are not representing them at the moment, and indeed I don’t think they are representing me, but I do feel that I still have a duty to carry on representing my constituents as a Lib Dem so will no be resigning from the party at this stage.  From the inside of the party I will of course continue to put as much pressure as I can on Clegg, Cable and the others who voted for this disastrous attack on Higher Education.  None of them would currently be getting my vote in a leadership election.

Remember: The Government Lib Dems may have let you (and me) down but I promise to carrying on striving to represent you and your views to Oxford City Council to the best of my ability and in line with what I and my party promised in May 2010.

4 thoughts on “My thoughts on the coalition vote on tuition fees

  1. martin hunt says:

    As a Lib Dem councillor myself I echo everything you say – I am lucky my LD MP voted against. You were elected in 2010 – lucky b##### – I am up for election in 2011!!!!!

  2. tonybrett says:

    Sadly my LibDem MP _was_ voted against. The conservatives ousted Dr Evan Harris with the slimmest or margins.

  3. Neil says:

    Most of the reasons I have voted Lib Dem in the past overlap witht the Greens.
    “I certainly won’t be joining any other parties as if people in Carfax ward had wanted a councillor from another party I guess they would have voted for one” They voted for you not your party. I suspect they will be voting for your party less in future.

  4. tonybrett says:

    Neil, I’m sure some people vote me me and I’m very flattered that they do but the reality is that a lot will be voting for the party. That’s why you see so few independent councillors. It’s a shame but that’s the way it is.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *